“There is hope,” reads the statement above the online bio for Richard Soper, MD, a specialist in addiction medicine and addiction psychiatry, but he admits to feeling pessimistic at times given the persistence of ineffective, punitive responses to the opioid epidemic.
Across his decades as a health care leader—as a clinician and in his previous service on the American Society of Addiction Medicine’s (ASAM) board of directors and as ASAM representative on the AMA Opioid Task Force—Dr. Soper has seen and felt progress in medical and policy circles toward understanding and treating substance-use disorder as a chronic condition like asthma, diabetes or hypertension.
Editor's note: This story is part of a new topic hub that centralizes the AMA’s essential tools, resources and content to help you in Advocating for Patients and Physicians.
But today, he said, that forward movement sometimes seems elusive given payment and regulatory barriers that interfere with patients’ access to evidence-based care amid an epidemic that kills hundreds of Americans each day.
“Bottom line: The pendulum is swinging back,” said Dr. Soper. “It’s swinging back to judging substance use as a character flaw, not a medical disorder.”
Prior authorization tightens grip
Dr. Soper, addiction medicine chief at the Center for Behavioral Wellness in Nashville, says he’s seeing a tightening up of prior-authorization policies, a return to fail-first requirements, pharmacies refusing to fill prescriptions and law enforcement acting as gatekeepers deciding who gets access to clinical treatment.
“People want treatment; they are literally dying because they can’t get treatment,” he said. “It’s frustrating. It’s fatiguing.”
Other factors shaping Dr. Soper’s attitude include sharp increases in the cost of lifesaving drugs such as naloxone and buprenorphine, an increase in administrative burdens, and Medicaid’s 16-bed size limit on inpatient treatment centers. (As part of his declaration of a public health emergency related to the opioid crisis, President Donald Trump announced that he would grant waivers to states requesting relief from the 16-bed limit.)
Dr. Soper finds insurance plans that fail to cover non-opioid alternatives for pain treatment are particularly challenging for him and his patients.
“It’s not that there are a lack of alternatives; there’s a lack of reimbursement for alternatives,” he said. “It just befuddles me that we allow insurance companies to say, ‘We know physical therapy helps. We’re just not going to pay for it.’”
2 steps to take now
There are two things that physicians and other clinicians can do now to help end the opioid epidemic, Dr. Soper said. The first is to recognize that all physicians “have these kinds of patients.” The second is for physicians to do their part to end the judgmental attitudes substance-use disorder patients are subjected to.
“Even physicians are still stigmatizing,” Dr. Soper said. When patients struggle with treatment, it becomes incumbent on doctors to “pull them closer, then break it down and find why they did what they did.”
The latest statistics in Tennessee are as grim as they are elsewhere in the nation and the Appalachian states in particular. There were 1,631 Tennesseans who died from drug overdoses in 2016, the most ever, according to the Tennessee Department of Health (TDH). It represents a 12 percent increase from the 1,451 deaths reported last year.
Heroin was linked to 260 Tennessee deaths in 2016, a 26 percent increase from 2015. And overdose deaths related to fentanyl rose 74 percent in 2016—up to 294 from 169, the TDH reported. In 2015, Tennessee’s opioid-overdose death rate was 11th highest among U.S. states.
Signs of hope
Despite these numbers, Dr. Soper said too many pharmacies fail to carry naloxone. In light of that, he praised CVS Health pharmacies in Nashville for executing standing orders to allow naloxone to be dispensed without a prescription. Walgreens recently announced that it will stock the opioid overdose antidote in each of its 8,000-plus pharmacies across the country.
“There is hope,” Dr. Soper concluded. “But it’s hard. One of the motivations I still have is that there are a few people still alive because I was one of the tools they used.”
More on this